NYC’S CAN’T-MISS THEATRE - SEE THESE SHOWS BEFORE THEY’RE GONE
Contributor - Jack Bartholet | Lifestyle Consultant • 3/20/25
We've all been there—you ask about weekend plans, and someone mentions going to Luna Luna at The Shed. You think, “I’ll grab tickets,” only to hear, “It closes tomorrow.” That show you’ve been eyeing for months? Gone in an instant.
Unlike streaming services that alert us when content is leaving, New York City—the cultural heart of theatre—offers no such reminder. You tell yourself, “I’ll definitely catch that,” but before you know it, the final curtain falls.
As we look ahead to summer getaways, don’t forget about the springtime magic still unfolding in NYC. With limited engagements and upcoming closing dates, consider this your reminder to grab tickets before they’re gone.
DON’T LET THESE NYC SHOWS PASS YOU BY
APRIL CLOSINGS: ACT FAST!
A Streetcar Named Desire – Through April 6
Paul Mescal delivers a commanding performance as Stanley Kowalski in Tennessee Williams’ iconic drama, directed by Rebecca Frecknall. This electrifying production, which has captivated audiences at BAM, is a must-see. If you haven’t yet experienced this intense revival, now is the time. And while you’re in Brooklyn, let our consultants recommend the perfect dining spot to complete your evening.
Joy Behar: My First Ex-Husband – Through April 20
You know and love her from The View, and now Joy Behar brings her signature wit to the stage with My First Ex-Husband, a 90-minute comedic storytelling event. Featuring Judy Gold, Susan Lucci, Tonya Pinkins, and Cathy Moriarty, this production is packed with powerhouse women and plenty of laughs.
Ghosts – Through April 27
Lincoln Center Theater presents Henrik Ibsen’s Ghosts, adapted by Mark O’Rowe and directed by Jack O’Brien. The star-studded cast includes Billy Crudup, Lily Rabe, Hamish Linklater, Levon Hawke, and Ella Beatty. This gripping psychological drama, set against the stunning backdrop of Lincoln Center’s Vivian Beaumont Theater, is both haunting and revelatory.
MAY MUST-SEES:
Vanya – Through May 11
Andrew Scott, widely known for his award-winning role as "Hot Priest" in Fleabag, brings Anton Chekhov’s Uncle Vanya to life in a radical solo adaptation. Direct from a sold-out London run, Scott embodies eight different characters in an intimate, immersive performance at the Lucille Lortel Theatre. This production is nothing short of theatrical magic.
JUNE HIGHLIGHTS:
Stephen Sondheim’s Old Friends – Through June 1
Broadway legends Bernadette Peters and Lea Salonga lead a celebration of Stephen Sondheim’s incomparable songbook. Featuring an all-star ensemble and a heartfelt tribute to one of musical theatre’s greatest composers, this limited engagement is truly one for the history books.
Othello – Through June 8
A Shakespearean classic starring two Hollywood heavyweights: Denzel Washington as Othello and Jake Gyllenhaal as Iago. Directed by Kenny Leon, this highly anticipated production has been the talk of the town since its announcement. Don’t miss your chance to secure tickets before the final performance at the Public Theater.
Good Night, and Good Luck – Through June 8
George Clooney makes his Broadway debut in this stage adaptation of his acclaimed film, joined by Ilana Glazer in a gripping production that examines McCarthy-era journalism. Directed by David Cromer and playing at the Winter Garden Theatre, this play explores truth, integrity, and the media’s responsibility in shaping public perception.
Oh Mary! – Through June 28
Cole Escola’s darkly comedic play has been extended multiple times, with audiences and celebrities alike raving about its hilarity. Jennifer Aniston, Whoopi Goldberg, and Meryl Streep have all stopped by to witness Escola’s outrageous take on Mary Todd Lincoln. With Tituss Burgess stepping into the role before Escola’s return, this show is already generating Tony buzz. Catch it before it’s too late.
FINAL CURTAIN CALLS IN JULY:
Operation Mincemeat – Through July 13
The hit London import that turned WWII espionage into a musical comedy is making waves on Broadway. Chronicling a daring covert operation, this critically acclaimed production blends history, humor, and show-stopping performances. Playing at the Golden Theatre, it's a must-see for fans of sharp, clever theatre.
Sunset Boulevard – Through July 13
Jamie Lloyd’s reimagining of Sunset Boulevard has quickly become the hottest ticket in town. Nicole Scherzinger’s transformation into Norma Desmond is nothing short of mesmerizing, and the production’s cinematic aesthetic has left audiences in awe. Having attended over a dozen performances ourselves, we can confidently say: this is Broadway at its coolest. Don’t miss your chance to witness it before the final show.
This is what we do best. At Four Hundred, we take pride in curating unforgettable cultural experiences for our members. Our extensive network of trusted partners ensures access to premium seating without the hassle of third-party resale sites.
Submit a request today and let us handle the details. After all, in the world of theatre, the only thing worse than a sold-out show is saying, “I wish I had seen that.”
Contributor — Jack Bartholet | Lifestyle Consultant
Jack effortlessly transitions from the entertainment industry to the world of luxury hospitality and travel, bringing a rich background of collaboration with celebrated artists and extensive personal travel experiences. When not consulting, he can be seen onstage with cabaret and theatre performances. Jack's enduring passion centers on fostering a sense of belonging for LGBTQ travelers wherever their journey takes them.
